Mphwiyo Shooting Case: Kumwembe Application for Judge Recusal Dismissed

Lilongwe Court 

Justice Michael Mtambo has on Friday, dismissed judge recusal application made by MacDonald Kumwembe, suspected shooter in the attempted murder of Paul Mphwiyo, for lack of merit.

His application has also earned him a four months prison sentence for sarcasm, rudeness and demeaning the judge.

Justice Mtambo has refused to recuse himself from hearing the case for a second time now following application that was made by third accused person Raphael Kasambara which the judge had also dismissed in June. 

Kumwembe applied for the recusal of presiding Judge Mtambo on grounds of bias and that he perceived that the judge has already intended to make a ruling against him.

Kumwembe being handcuffed for contempt 

The application, which has provoked the judge to send him to prison, therein Kumwembe likened Judge Michael Mtambo to a thief by describing him as a “modern day, Robin Hood” (a heroic outlaw in English folklore portrayed as robbing from the rich to give to the poor)

Kumwembe also in his application added a CV which he claims belongs to the judge and that it speaks volume of the possible bias which may result him being found guilty and convicted of the alleged crime he is answering.

But in his ruling, the judge argued that Kumwembe application failed to lay foundation for judge recusal and that the claimed CV does not add any substance to justify the recusal of the Judge.

“Anybody can pick any document from anywhere and say that this is a CV of someone” said Mtambo as he discredits the validity of the alleged CV.

Kumwembe being walked to Maula Prison 

While the Judge wondered as of who served Kumwembe the claimed CV and the motive behind, Justice Mtambo also mentioned that the said CV does not set grounds for judge recusal and it must have been sourced through theft.

“CVs are confidential documents…. and you can’t just get someone CV. That is stealing“ he then added that such actions may pressure other judges to recuse themselves in fear that if they take up the case someone will dig up something from them.

Meanwhile the case has been adjourned for 24th to 26th of September 2015. The court is in the next sitting expected to continue with pending state application for the bail revocation of McDonald Kumwembe.

The Judge has also asked the court to submit on whether the court can of its own motion review the bail status of the third accused person Raphael Kasambara. This comes after the court observed that that there has been no cooperation from defense after it was learnt that Kasambara has been aiding Kumwembe on several issues including the filing, typing, and printing of judge recusal application and on claims made by Kumwembe of the ownership of the alleged CV for the judge. 

Kumwembe and Pika Manondo were found with case to answer on attempted murder and conspiracy to murder former of former budget director Paul Mphwiyi while Lawyer Raphael Kasambara was found with case to answer on conspiracy to commit murder. 

Cross Examination of Kumwembe’ Application for Judge Recusal

During Friday court sitting, Kumwembe sought for Chichewa translator for the cross examination of his application for the judge recusal a development which led the state to ascertain that Kumwembe had not written the application by himself as the application had been crafted in such a very good English.

Mary Kachale: Kumwembe was used by
Ralph And Arnolds 

The State insisted that Kumwembe was being used by Ralph and Arnold Associates which belongs to Raphael Kasambara for his application for the judge recusal.

Director of Public Prosecution (DPP) Mary Kachale said all documents from Kumwembe were typed and printed by Ralph and Arnolds Associate of which Kumwembe denied.

“All these ideas were not yours and you are just being used by Ralph and Arnolds” claimed Kachale though Kumwembe denied the assertion by stating that he typed and printed the documents at some internet cafes he can’t remember their names and exact location but were in area 4.

When asked more about the CV which he claim to be of Justice Mtambo, Kumwembe said unnamed “well-wisher” just brought it at his home then he went with it to Raphael Kasambara who identified it as Mtambo’s CV because of its signature.

The state also told court that Kumwembe has been following the presiding Judge for a long time to the extent that he knew extra security personnel that were assigned for the Judge. However, Kumwembe denied by stating that he was tipped by unknown police officer whom he met at a pub in Lilongwe. 

Asked to describe who Robin Hood is, Kumwembe said must be a judge somewhere else, an answer which the state further justified that Kumwembe was not the person who wrote the application for judge recusal.